What insurance should health plan fiduciaries carry beyond the fidelity bond?

Last updated October 2, 2026

Fiduciary liability insurance protects fiduciaries personally against breach claims; D&O covers corporate management decisions; E&O covers professional service errors; cyber insurance responds to breaches. Each answers a different risk — the bond alone protects only the plan against dishonesty.

Once the mandatory fidelity bond is in place, the remaining coverages are voluntary but widely carried, because each answers a question the others don't:

  • Fiduciary liability insurance: defends and indemnifies the fiduciaries themselves — committee members included — against ERISA breach claims. This is the policy that stands between a lawsuit and personal assets.
  • Directors & officers (D&O): covers corporate management decisions; many D&O policies exclude ERISA claims, which is exactly why standalone fiduciary coverage exists.
  • Errors & omissions (E&O): professional liability for service errors — most relevant to organizations delivering services.
  • Cyber insurance: breach response, notification costs, and liability when plan data is compromised.

Reviewing limits, ERISA exclusions, and who counts as an insured — annually, in committee — turns a stack of policies into an actual protection strategy.

Thanks for your feedback!

Put these answers to work

Fiduciary In A Box walks your team through every one of these requirements step by step — documenting decisions, organizing files, and keeping your plan compliant year-round.

See how FIAB works